Pizza stone or baking tray? The best method for crispy Italian-style pizza

If you love pizza like they serve it at an Italian restaurant – with a crispy crust, airy edge, and perfectly baked toppings – you’ve probably wondered: pizza stone or baking sheet? In this article, you’ll learn which method really is best, what to watch out for when baking, and tips to help you get the most out of your oven.

Is a pizza stone worth the extra cost?

A pizza stone holds a lot of heat and evenly transfers it to the pizza base – similar to a real stone oven. This results in an especially crispy crust that’s hard to achieve with a regular baking sheet. For those who bake pizza or flatbreads regularly, it’s a worthwhile investment.

👉 Discover our authentic Italian olive oils, perfect for enhancing your pizza’s flavor!

Can I make great pizza with just a baking sheet?

Yes – but technique matters. It’s important to preheat the baking sheet so the dough gets heat right away. Also, use a thin sheet and bake the pizza on the lowest rack. Still, the heat distribution of a pizza stone is superior.

If you want to start without extra tools, a baking sheet is a good beginning – with some practice, you can get excellent results.

Pizza: pizza stone, pizza steel, or baking sheet – which is better?

Here’s a quick comparison:

• Pizza stone: authentic flavor, good heat distribution, requires preheating.
• Pizza steel: even better heat conduction, very crispy, but heavier and more expensive.
• Baking sheet: cheap and always available, but not ideal for maximum crispiness.

For true pizza lovers, pizza stone or steel is clearly the best choice.

How long and at what temperature should I preheat a pizza stone?

A pizza stone should be preheated for at least 45–60 minutes at 250–300 °C (480–570 °F), preferably on the lowest oven rack. This allows the stone to store enough energy to cook the dough quickly – ensuring that typical Italian pizza texture.

 

How do I safely transfer the pizza onto the hot stone?

The best tool is a pizza peel or a thin board. You can prepare the pizza on parchment paper and place it on the stone with the paper. After 1–2 minutes, the paper can be easily removed.

Make sure the dough is well floured so it doesn’t stick during transfer.

Which method produces the crispiest pizza – stone, steel, or sheet?

Pizza steel yields the crispiest crust because it transfers heat faster than stone. The classic pizza stone is a close second. The baking sheet ranks third – especially with thicker dough, the bottom can stay a bit soft.

Our tip: For maximum crunch, choose pizza steel or stone and finish with very high top/bottom heat or grill function.

Can a pizza stone crack or break?

Yes, if you heat it too quickly or pour cold liquid on a hot stone. Important: always place the stone in a cold oven and heat it together with the oven. Also, be careful when removing it and don’t place it on cold surfaces.

How do I best clean a pizza stone?

Never use water and soap! Let the stone cool completely and scrape off residue with a wooden spatula. Burnt spots are normal and don’t affect the flavor. Optionally, brush dry with a grill brush.

Can I make pizza crispy on a baking sheet?

Yes, with a few tricks: preheat the sheet in the oven, use the lowest rack, and choose a thin, dark baking sheet. A wire rack can also help deliver heat directly to the bottom.

👉 For true flavor, you need real Italian tomato sauces – find them here, straight from southern Italy.

Who benefits more from pizza steel instead of a stone?

If you bake pizza or bread often, steel is the most durable and high-performing option. It’s tougher, conducts heat faster, and tolerates temperature swings well. Ideal for experienced home bakers.

Conclusion: What’s the best method for pizza at home?

If you bake pizza frequently and value authenticity, pizza stone (or steel) is the best choice. For occasional bakers, baking sheet with some tricks works fine. The choice depends on your standards, budget, and patience with preheating.

👉 Check out our gourmet gift boxes – perfect for pizza nights or as gifts for Italy lovers!

Your turn now!

Want to bake pizza like in Italy? Give it a try – with original Italian ingredients directly from our Pareto Shop. Authentic. Direct from the producer. Lovingly packed.

👉 Get your ingredients now and start your pizza upgrade: To the products